Mérieux NutriSciences Completes Acquisition of Certified Group Learn More.
Introducing Our New Podcast. Listen Now and Subscribe.
Assemble Your EMP Package. Get Started!
DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS

COA Trends: Turning Lab Data Into Food Safety Strategy

Subscribe To Blog

Subscribe

COA Trends: Turning Lab Data Into Food Safety Strategy
12:14

 

Even if a product meets its specifications, you can't always disregard it. Certificates of Analysis (COAs), elemental analysis, and authenticity tests all provide a response to one question: does this sample conform to the specified limits? When you look at the same data over months and across suppliers, it answers a more insightful question: Is something changing in my supply chain? For dietary supplement and nutraceutical manufacturers who purchase botanicals, minerals, and protein powders, that second question is the point at which chemistry data becomes a strategic issue. Analytical chemistry in food testing provides more than individual pass-or-fail results. By reviewing historical laboratory data, manufacturers can identify patterns in ingredient quality, food contaminant testing, and supplier performance that may warrant further investigation.

What does an analysis of COA trends reveal that a single result cannot?

A trend analysis carried out by COA shows whether the quality of an ingredient is remaining stable, slowly changing, or becoming erratic even though each lot still conforms. Two lots can satisfy the same limit for heavy metals yet have very different levels of contaminants. When each COA is examined separately, it appears satisfactory, but when they are looked at together, they might tell a different story.

This is in keeping with what the regulators expect. According to the FDA’s 2024 dietary supplement compliance programme, supplier qualification records, incoming certificate of analysis, laboratory controls, and documented quality decisions are some of the areas that are examined during inspections (FDA, 2024). As part of the dietary supplement CGMP rule, manufacturers are required to establish component specifications and adhere to procedures for verifying them (21 CFR §§ 111.70–111.75). Having a well-organized dataset makes it much easier to give a reason for having accepted, investigated, or rejected a material.

What chemistry data should you be recording?

Make sure to keep required context so that the results can be fairly compared. Relying merely on concentrations is not adequate since different methods or reporting limits can make two figures appear comparable when in fact they aren't. A helpful record should include:

  • Supplier and ingredient: supplier name, material grade, and country or region of origin

  • Lot details: lot number, manufacturing and sampling dates, and any known sourcing changes

  • Results: concentrations, units, specifications, and detection or quantitation limits

  • Method: analytical method, laboratory, and performance data

  • History: past deviations, investigations, and corrective actions

  • Decisions: lot disposition, added testing, and supplier follow-up

Once this situation exists, clear patterns become evident, and exceptions become promptly identifiable. For example, one supplier provides consistent results over a number of years whereas another varies from shipment to shipment. This indicates the areas in which verification should be carried out. Even if a company has a strong record, it does not mean that less testing is justified, particularly where regulations or risks specific to the ingredient require ongoing verification.

What do heavy metal trends indicate regarding emerging ingredient risks?

An increasing level of lead, cadmium, arsenic, or mercury from one batch to another may indicate that there has been a change in the sourcing, growing, or processing before any batch fails. These elements are most significant in relation to ingredients that are affected by agricultural and environmental conditions, such as many botanicals.

The majority of laboratories determine the elements by using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), a method which enables multiple elements to be detected in a single analysis at very low concentrations. According to FDA’s Elemental Analysis Manual Method 4.7 (revised in April 2025), microwave-assisted digestion is followed by ICP-MS when analysing food for elements such as lead, cadmium, arsenic, chromium, and mercury (FDA, 2025).

Consider the following hypothetical situation. A manufacturer gets six successive lots of a botanical ingredient against an internal lead specification of 0.50 mg/kg; the results rise from approximately 0.15 mg/kg in the first lot to about 0.45 mg/kg in the sixth lot, and all of the lots are found to be acceptable. Nevertheless, the lead level has increased by roughly a factor of three, which should lead to a discussion with the supplier.

The correct course of action is not to reject it automatically. You should first check that the increase is truly representative of a change in the material by examining the sampling procedure, the method's performance, and the measurement uncertainty. Then inquire into the source of the raw material and the corresponding processing workflow. The findings from this inquiry will then shape the consideration of further testing on the next batches. Many teams establish an internal investigation threshold below the specification limit in order to initiate this kind of review, which allows for a proactive approach to a potential out-of-specification situation. This practice prevents a reactive response to the issue, which can be preceded by costly shutdowns or product recalls. This threshold supplements the specification and must have a clear scientific basis that is documented. It must never take the place of the acceptance criteria.

The trend data also supports the Proposition 65 assessments. The safe harbour levels set by OEHHA—the No Significant Risk Levels for cancer and the Maximum Allowable Dose Levels for reproductive toxicity—are based on exposure (OEHHA, 2025). Yet focusing on the concentration listed on a certificate of analysis is only half the calculation; the serving size and daily intake are also important. Historical data that is consistent makes it easier to construct and justify the exposure assessments, and a change in concentration clearly indicates that these assessments need to be looked at again.

At what stage do surprising results show the presence of economic fraud?

The change in chemistry may be due to the ingredient itself. Examples of economically motivated adulteration are replacing a substance with a cheaper one, diluting the product, or misrepresenting its composition. Ingredients of high value, such as standardised botanical extracts, are frequently targeted.

A close examination is warranted if there is a sudden change in marker compound levels since this might be due to natural variation, differences in processing, analytical interference, or substitution; a single unusual result tells us little, but a pattern taken together with other evidence can provide a compelling reason for carrying out identity testing.

Marín and others in 2025 look at the role of spectroscopy, chromatography, and mass spectrometry in detecting adulteration and in verifying authenticity; they also point out the importance of joining analytical results with information relating to the supply chain and traceability. In practice, this involves the procurement and quality teams checking each other's findings to see whether prices have changed, whether the origin has altered, and whether the supplier's documentation still makes sense. When doubts are raised by chemical fingerprinting, a second analytical method can be used to confirm the situation. The method chosen must be appropriate for the suspected adulterant and for the material being tested.

What is the way of deciding what action to take when a result seems wrong?

Use a short, documented set of prompts so every team responds the same way:

  1. To check whether the result is reliable, you should examine the sampling, the appropriateness of the method, the uncertainty, and the lab quality controls.

  2. Should the change be considered significant? Check it against historical data and the amount expected to vary.

  3. What might account for it? Perhaps it is due to the sourcing, processing, formulation, or the practices of the supplier.

  4. Does this have an effect on quality or on regulatory risk? Examine the specifications, the exposure assessments, and the testing requirements.

  5. What constitutes a justified course of action? The possible options are confirmatory testing, a supplier investigation, increased monitoring, or corrective action.

The outcome will vary according to the ingredient and the level of risk. It is helpful to have input from different teams, as different areas of supply chain awareness provide a greater scope of insight. For example, a laboratory analyst might notice an odd pattern, whereas the procurement team will know that the supplier has just changed regions. In this way, an increasing trend in cadmium levels is usually explained, which is why the quality, procurement, and regulatory teams should all work with the same data.

It is critical to regularly review your testing plan due to the unavoidable changes that will occur to the ingredients, the suppliers, and the regulations; any changes to the frequency or scope must be based on a scientific reason and should be in line with the applicable requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions About Chemistry Testing and COA Trends 


Use the chemistry data offered by Mérieux NutriSciences.

Your results should not only clear the way for release, but also allow for a deepened understanding of how to make informed decisions regarding your process. Mérieux NutriSciences offers its analytical chemistry expertise so manufacturers of food and dietary supplements can understand ingredient variability, assess supplier performance, and decide when further investigation is needed. If you require ICP-MS testing for heavy metals, targeted studies into contaminants, or a comprehensive testing program, our team can assist you in selecting the appropriate methods for your products.

Find out more about our Chemistry Testing Services as well as discover the ways in which we can help you with ingredient verification, contaminant testing, and meeting your food safety objectives.


References

Marín, X., Grau-Noguer, E., Gervilla-Cantero, G., Ripollés-Ávila, C., & Castillo, M. (2025). Emerging technologies for detecting food fraud: A review of the present landscape in the 2020s. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 165, Article 105313. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tifs.2025.105313

Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment. (2025, April 21). Proposition 65 law and regulations. https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65/law/proposition-65-law-and-regulations

U.S. Food and Drug Administration. (2024). Dietary supplements—Foreign and domestic inspections, sampling, and imports (Compliance Program 7321.008). https://www.fda.gov/food/compliance-enforcement-food/food-compliance-programs

U.S. Food and Drug Administration. (2025, April). Inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometric determination of arsenic, cadmium, chromium, lead, mercury, and other elements in food using microwave-assisted digestion (Elemental Analysis Manual, Section 4.7, Version 1.3). https://www.fda.gov/food/laboratory-methods-food/elemental-analysis-manual-eam-food-and-related-products

U.S. Food and Drug Administration. (n.d.). Current good manufacturing practice in manufacturing, packaging, labeling, or holding operations for dietary supplements (21 CFR Part 111, §§ 111.70–111.75). Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-111

Similar Posts

Subscribe To Our Blog.

Get exclusive content delivered to your inbox!